I gave COMING OF AGE just four starts because Terkel's increasing rigidity in sticking with liberal interviewees deprives readers of an honest cross-section of views. Despite this flaw, COMING OF AGE remains a moving effort.
In addition to a zest for life, which they all share (few, despite physical infirmities, consider themselves »retired«), a few common themes emerge in these recollections. Whatever their background, almost all were affected by the Depression and World War II and a surprising number felt the blight of McCarthyism.
Yet most view the young today as facing a tougher road than they did. And while they all claim to find younger people invigorating, most deplore the modern lack of community feeling, the emphasis on self, the ignorance of history and unwillingness to learn from the struggles of the past.
The Catholic priest who was a gung-ho soldier in World War II, learned about race in a poor southern parish and went on to join the Berrigans in protesting the Vietnam War, says that what's »lacking today is a national cause in which all can join.« You could say he spoke too soon or those were the days.
Jazz musician Milt Hinton's grandmother was a slave of Jefferson Davis. He recalls the apprenticeship of his youth, sitting in with the greats. When prompted he cites the more absurd of racial indignities faced touring the south but prefers to dwell on the good times, voicing regret that those opportunities don't exist for today's young black musicians.
All of these oldsters have strong convictions about what's wrong with the world, although surprisingly few sound cranky about it. »I'm deeply accustomed to giving advice that is not heard,« says economist John Kenneth Galbraith, a long time critic of »private affluence and public squalor.«
Many of them find a new freedom in old age. »Young people don't have this liberty,« says environmental activist David Brower. »They can't alienate themselves too much from the system.«
Some seem to live almost wholly in the present. A Nisei school teacher who spent World War II in an internment camp spends her entire interview enthusing about the young children she teaches and the future before them.
An admiral who directs the Center for Defense Information, a whistle-blowing group, was a model naval officer. »My fervor and dissent has increased … as you get older, you realize that whether it be a justice of the Supreme Court or the president of the United States, he's just a human being subject to human foibles.«
Terkel, a feisty fighter himself, has naturally picked a large proportion of social and political activists – people who see the world as imperfect then and imperfect now – but always worth fighting for. This is an invigorating and thoughtful collection and a fine perspective on the last century.